China Equities Lag US Stocks by Record 2.095 Valuation Ratio

The historical divergence underscores growing investor concerns that Chinese shares are entering a persistent value trap driven by soft domestic consumer demand and hesitant state-backed intervention funds. As Chinese blue-chip equities descend into bear market territory, U.S. markets continue to pull ahead despite experiencing their own late-week pullback.

Historic Valuation Divergence Across Global Benchmarks

The record gap between U.S. and Chinese equity benchmarks reflects decades of comparative price action. When trading concluded on Thursday, October 22, the S&P 500 closed at 2.095 times the Shanghai Composite, surpassing the previous record ratio of 2.088 established on September 19, 2024, in data extending back to 1997.

A similar record emerged in Hong Kong trading. The ratio comparing the S&P 500 to the Hang Seng Index reached a record high of 0.334 in data going back to 1990. Both price-level ratios eased slightly on Friday to 2.066 and 0.330, respectively, as mainland markets staged a brief late-week rally. Nonetheless, the overall valuation gap hit its widest margin on record for the week ended October 23.

For dollar-denominated fund investors, the gap expanded to historic levels as well. Measured in U.S. dollars with dividends included, the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust ($SPY) hit a record high ratio relative to the iShares MSCI China ETF ($MCHI) on October 22, based on data tracking back to 2011.

Through October 23, the S&P 500 has advanced 11.4% in 2026, according to Yahoo Finance. Over the same period, the Shanghai Composite has declined 7.0%, while the Hang Seng Index has fallen 9.9%. Consequently, the S&P 500 leads the Shanghai Composite by approximately 18 percentage points in 2026 and leads $MCHI by roughly 30 percentage points, with $MCHI falling 18.4% year-to-date.

China's mainland blue-chip benchmark, the CSI 300, dropped 1.8% to 4,036.30 on Thursday, marking its lowest closing level since July 2025 and officially entering bear market territory. The index ended Thursday down 20.2% from its June 22 closing peak. Simultaneously, the Shanghai Composite fell 1.5% to a more than one-year low, while the Hang Seng Tech Index hit a two-year low.

Chinese Tech Weakness and Policy Drag Weigh on Sentiment

Individual mega-cap technology equities suffered notable sell-offs during the week. Shares of Alibaba Group ($BABA) declined by more than 6%, while Tencent dropped 2.9%. Market participants questioned the durability of valuations and earnings growth tied to artificial intelligence. Sentiment was further damped by Beijing's incremental approach to economic stimulus, alongside a government move to tax offshore trusts held by shareholders in Hong Kong-listed Chinese corporations.

"The market is in the dump," stated Hao Hong, chief investment officer at Lotus Asset Management, according to Yahoo Finance. Hong added that the National Team—the collective term for China's state-backed funds that purchase equities to stabilize trading—"has been rather hesitant to make a move".

State-backed intervention materialized briefly on Friday as heavy trading volume in preferred exchange-traded funds lifted the CSI 300 by 1.7% and the Shanghai Composite by 0.9%. Despite Friday's bounce, the CSI 300 still lost 1.6% for the week. That result extended the CSI 300's losing streak to 11 consecutive weeks—the longest sustained weekly decline since the index was created in 2005—leaving it approximately 19% below its June peak.

Analysts at Morgan Stanley noted that "weak domestic demand and liquidity headwinds persist, while valuations have yet to reach an outright bottom," according to Yahoo Finance. The widening record ratio occurred even as U.S. shares wobbled on Friday, with the S&P 500 declining 0.52%.

Specific China-focused exchange-traded funds illustrated varying degrees of weakness across sectors:

• The KraneShares CSI China Internet ETF ($KWEB) slipped 0.30% on Friday to $23.14, losing about 5.2% for the week. $KWEB is down 32.0% in 2026, carrying a one-year total return of -37.79% due to tech valuation concerns.
• The iShares China Large-Cap ETF ($FXI), managing $3.78 billion in assets, dipped 0.43% to $32.31. $FXI is down 15.6% in 2026 with a one-year return of -17.20%, supported in part by its heavy exposure to large banking stocks.
• The broader iShares MSCI China ETF ($MCHI) fell 0.04% to $49.00, finishing just above its 52-week low of $48.65, with a one-year return of -20.79%.

The market debate centers on valuation versus fundamentals. Bullish arguments emphasize that Chinese stocks trade at a historic discount relative to U.S. equities, backed by potential intervention from state funds. Conversely, bearish arguments highlight sluggish domestic demand, piecemeal policy stimulus, new offshore trust taxation risks, and the delayed intervention of the National Team.

What to Watch

• Tuesday, Oct 27: Visa Inc - Class A ($V) earnings Q4 2026 — after the close (consensus EPS 3.51).
• Wednesday, Oct 28: Alphabet Inc - Class A ($GOOGL) earnings Q3 2026 — after the close (consensus EPS 3.11).
• Wednesday, Oct 28: Microsoft Corporation ($MSFT) earnings Q1 2027 — after the close (consensus EPS 4.82).
• Thursday, Oct 29: Amazon.com Inc ($AMZN) earnings Q3 2026 — after the close (consensus EPS 2.00).

Related on rawfin.tv

• Market Open — every episode